An RTI (Right to Information) inquiry has revealed that Indian embassies are yet to disclose the details of expenditure incurred during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visits to 13 nations in 2024. The lack of transparency has raised questions about government accountability and the costs associated with international diplomatic engagements.
The RTI Inquiry and Its Implications
The Right to Information Act was enacted in India to ensure transparency and accountability in governance. Through an RTI request, a citizen sought information regarding the total expenditure incurred on PM Modi’s foreign trips in 2024. This inquiry was meant to clarify the costs of travel, accommodation, security arrangements, delegation expenses, and other related financial allocations.
However, responses from embassies have either been delayed, denied, or provided with incomplete information. This has led to concerns about why such information is not readily available and whether there is a reluctance to disclose the financial details of high-profile diplomatic visits.
Diplomatic Significance and Public Interest
PM Modi’s international visits have always played a crucial role in fostering bilateral relations, trade agreements, and global partnerships. These visits often involve high-stakes meetings with world leaders, discussions on investment opportunities, and strategic alliances.
While these trips contribute significantly to India’s diplomatic standing, the financial aspect of these visits is of great public interest. Taxpayer money is utilized for these diplomatic engagements, and citizens have a right to know how much is being spent and whether the costs are justified. Transparency in government spending, particularly in international travel, is essential for maintaining public trust and ensuring responsible financial management.
Government’s Response to RTI Query
Officials from the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) have acknowledged receiving the RTI inquiry and have assured that the required details will be made public once all embassies submit their reports. The MEA explained that compiling expenditure details involves coordination with multiple diplomatic missions and government agencies, which can cause delays.
However, transparency advocates argue that such delays undermine the purpose of the RTI Act. The Act was designed to ensure that information is provided in a timely manner, allowing citizens to scrutinize government actions effectively. Withholding or delaying financial details raises concerns about whether the government is reluctant to reveal the actual costs of these visits.
Breakdown of Expenditures on Foreign Trips
While the specific expenditure details for the 2024 trips remain undisclosed, previous disclosures provide an estimate of typical expenses incurred during official visits. These usually include:
- Air Travel Costs: Chartering special aircraft for the Prime Minister and the accompanying delegation
- Accommodation Expenses: High-security hotel bookings for the Prime Minister, officials, and security personnel
- Security Arrangements: Deployment of Special Protection Group (SPG) personnel, coordination with local security forces, and setting up security perimeters
- Event Hosting and Diplomatic Engagements: Organizing state banquets, business summits, and public addresses
- Delegation Expenses: Travel and lodging for ministers, business leaders, and journalists accompanying the Prime Minister
For example, past records have indicated that some foreign visits by Indian leaders have cost millions of dollars, depending on the duration, location, and number of officials involved.
Political Reactions and Public Debate
The delay in providing details of the expenditures has led to political debates. Opposition parties have criticized the government for its lack of transparency and have demanded that the expenditure details be made public immediately. They argue that taxpayers have the right to know how their money is being spent, especially when it comes to foreign diplomatic engagements.
Social media and public discourse have also been filled with discussions about the need for greater scrutiny over government spending on high-profile trips. Transparency activists and financial watchdogs have called for stronger mechanisms to ensure that such information is readily available without needing an RTI inquiry.
International Comparisons: How Other Nations Handle Diplomatic Expenses
Globally, many governments disclose travel expenditures for their leaders and diplomats. For instance:
- United States: The U.S. government regularly releases reports on the President’s travel expenditures, including Secret Service costs and official travel expenses.
- United Kingdom: The British government provides detailed spending reports on official visits made by the Prime Minister and government ministers.
- Canada: Travel costs for government officials are disclosed as part of public records.
In comparison, India’s process of revealing such expenditures appears less transparent and more bureaucratic. Advocates argue that India should adopt a more proactive approach to disclosing government spending on diplomatic engagements.
The Need for Greater Financial Transparency
To improve transparency and accountability, experts suggest the following measures:
- Proactive Disclosure: The government should publish details of international travel expenses without requiring an RTI request.
- Standardized Reporting: Embassies and ministries should follow a structured reporting system to ensure timely and accurate expenditure reports.
- Parliamentary Oversight: Regular parliamentary reviews should be conducted on government spending related to diplomatic travel.
- Public Access to Data: Citizens should have easy access to government expenditure reports through official portals.
Conclusion
The lack of immediate disclosure regarding PM Modi’s 2024 foreign visit expenditures highlights broader concerns about transparency in government spending. While the government has assured that the details will be made public, the delay in responding to RTI requests raises critical questions about financial accountability.
As India continues to strengthen its global presence through high-level diplomatic visits, ensuring financial transparency in these engagements remains essential. Whether or not the embassies release the expenditure details in a timely manner will be a key indicator of the government’s commitment to openness and public accountability.
Do follow Uae stories for more Updates
